NFL Week 12 roundtable: Giants’ QB plan post-Jones, NFC West race, is Bo Nix legit OROY contender?

You’ll be able to formally depend the New York Giants among the many groups whose offseason shall be constructed round discovering its subsequent franchise quarterback.

Daniel Jones’ being benched after which launched is only one improvement highlighting league happenings main as much as Sunday’s Week 12 motion. The Giants host the Tampa Bay Buccaneers with fan favourite Tommy DeVito in line to start out.

Elsewhere on this week’s roundtable, our NFL writers Mike Sando, Zak Keefer and Jeff Howe talk about the NFC West. Might it’s the league’s most fascinating division title race?

What in regards to the Offensive Rookie of the 12 months race? Is the Denver Broncos’ Bo Nix (or one other rookie quarterback) closing in on the Washington Commanders’ Jayden Daniels? Although Anthony Richardson has redeemed himself in Indianapolis, how will he and the Colts fare in opposition to the thrill noticed that’s the Detroit Lions? The 11-point favourite Kansas Metropolis Chiefs — sans Taylor Swift — go to Charlotte and the Carolina Panthers for the primary time in eight years. The Harbaugh Bowl caps off Week 12 on Monday evening, too.

Learn extra on what’s catching our writers’ consideration this week.

The Daniel Jones period is over because the Giants host the Bucs. What’s subsequent for Jones? What does the Giants’ plan at quarterback appear like this offseason?

Howe: They tried to maneuver up for a high QB in April, and I’d anticipate the same effort — if not a extra concerted one — this spring. The Giants are nonetheless in rivalry for the No. 1 choose, so they may get their alternative of QBs, however the race has primarily been specializing in Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders. There isn’t a marquee prospect on this class, although, and there are personnel executives who’ve already mentioned they wouldn’t rank any of the 2025 QBs forward of the six first-rounders from April. The Giants, like each QB-desperate workforce, must be aggressive, however they will’t power it. As for Jones, he’ll enter the camp competitors vortex for groups that aren’t capable of finding a starting-caliber QB within the draft. It’s lately labored for the likes of Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold and Russell Wilson, so I’d extremely advocate a pleasant offensive system.

Sando: Jones initiatives as a backup someplace, probably with a workforce that has playoff aspirations and will stand to improve behind its starter. The Miami Dolphins are solely 4-6, however they might use an improve behind Tua Tagovailoa. The Arizona Cardinals have Clayton Tune. Tampa Bay has Kyle Trask. The Minnesota Vikings have Nick Mullens. Possibly these groups love their backups, however I might see groups of their conditions contemplating Jones.

As for the Giants, who shall be making the selections there? How excessive will their draft alternative be? Which veterans is likely to be out there? It’s simply manner too early to know what the Giants are going to do, primarily based on all of the necessary unknown variables. They should discover a veteran in a position to begin and probably develop so that they aren’t too depending on their subsequent drafted QB — particularly in 2025, which doesn’t appear like one of the best 12 months for drafting on the place.

Keefer: Jones goes to make some huge cash on this league as a succesful backup someplace, faraway from the expectations that include being a franchise man. I can’t see a workforce — barring an unexpected damage — rolling with him because the starter in Week 1 subsequent season. Not after what he’s placed on tape the final two seasons. And the Giants will discover themselves this spring backed into one of many worst corners in soccer: needing a quarterback in a draft that doesn’t characteristic lots of quarterback expertise. That’s brought about groups to succeed in previously, and it’s burned them for many years. New York can be sensible to go the veteran route earlier than the draft simply to be secure. I ponder whether the prospect of Justin Fields taking up would get Giants followers excited.

Daniel Jones was benched Monday after the New York Giants’ 2-8 begin to the season, throughout which he accomplished 63.3 p.c of his passes for two,070 yards, eight touchdowns and 7 interceptions via 10 video games. (Mario Hommes / DeFodi Pictures through Getty Pictures)

The Broncos, on the street in opposition to the Las Vegas Raiders on Sunday, are within the thick of the AFC playoff hunt. Is Bo Nix (or one other rookie QB) a reputable Offensive Rookie of the 12 months contender or is it nonetheless Jayden Daniels’ award to lose?

Howe: It’s Daniels’ award to lose, and Drake Maye is enjoying higher than Nix. If Daniels and the Commanders tumble whereas the Broncos snag a playoff spot, there’s completely an avenue for Nix to assert the award, however I’d nonetheless take Daniels over the sphere.

Sando: It’s Daniels’ award to lose, however there’s some uncertainty about how strongly he and that offense will end. Nix is unquestionably gaining on him from a manufacturing standpoint. We will see that within the desk beneath, which reveals manufacturing for Daniels, Nix and Maye over their previous six video games. That’s a giant change from early within the season.

Keefer: Mike is true — it’s not solely Bo Nix coming into the dialog however Drake Maye as properly, though he received’t be capable of boast the relative workforce success Daniels is having fun with in Washington and Nix is having fun with in Denver. Voters for most of these awards typically lean on turnaround tales, and for some time this season, Daniels was scripting one of the best one in soccer. He’s nonetheless in entrance, however how he responds to consecutive losses would possibly very properly find yourself deciding this award.

The Chiefs are 11-point favorites on the street in opposition to the Panthers and, presumably, they’ll bounce again Sunday. Does the loss in Buffalo mixed with the Lions’ continued rise change how you are feeling about Kansas Metropolis?

Howe: A bit, sure. If the Chiefs managed to beat the Buffalo Payments with a subpar efficiency, which may have been a wrap, however the Lions and Payments are decisively higher proper now. And although everyone seems to be ready for the Chiefs to get considerably higher as Patrick Mahomes positive aspects expertise together with his ability gamers, we shouldn’t overlook the actual fact Josh Allen and the Payments will do the identical. Nobody who has watched the playoffs for the previous half-decade is ever going to put in writing off the Chiefs, however they’re objectively behind Detroit and Buffalo coming into essentially the most pivotal stretch of the season.

Sando: The best way the Payments offense dealt with the Chiefs protection must be regarding for Kansas Metropolis. Kansas Metropolis can enhance because the season progresses as a result of it’s properly coached and will probably be growing key gamers as Isaiah Pacheco returns, Xavier Worthy positive aspects expertise, and so on. Nevertheless it appears like a great 12 months to be Detroit or Buffalo, all issues thought-about. The Chiefs are excellent however much less dominant than their report signifies.

Keefer: I discovered my lesson final 12 months. The common season merely doesn’t matter for the Chiefs. They’ve come to transcend soccer norms throughout their dynastic run. It doesn’t matter that loads of their wins this season have been unconvincing. Doesn’t matter that Travis Kelce has taken a step again. Doesn’t matter that Patrick Mahomes has appeared mediocre — or worse — for stretches. Doesn’t matter that they couldn’t shut out the Payments final week. They completely stay a reputable Tremendous Bowl contender and may beat anybody within the playoffs. Bear in mind, as Kansas Metropolis proved final 12 months, it’s not the workforce that appears one of the best in November and December, it’s the one which will get sizzling in January. Greater than any workforce on the market, it is aware of how to do this.

The Harbaugh Bowl takes place Monday evening. The Baltimore Ravens path within the AFC North title race. The 7-3 Los Angeles Chargers escaped the Cincinnati Bengals final week. There are many storylines on this one. Which one intrigues you essentially the most?

Howe: Earlier than the season, coaches and executives across the league predicted Justin Herbert would make a leap with Jim Harbaugh, who would prioritize the bottom sport and a high-level protection to enrich his quarterback. Harbaugh proceeded to run a conservative offense, however he’s given Herbert extra of an opportunity to let it rip as of late. If Herbert topples the Ravens, he’s going to earn critical MVP consideration.

Sando: I’m all for seeing whether or not the Chargers’ much-improved protection can sluggish Lamar Jackson with the good thing about no matter inside information they’ve from coordinators Jesse Minter and Greg Roman, who spent important time on the Ravens’ workers. Is that this a sport the Chargers can play on their phrases? What occurs if this sport picks up the place Chargers-Bengals left off? Will Justin Herbert hold tempo with Jackson in that case?

Scoop Metropolis Publication

Free, every day NFL updates direct to your inbox.

Free, every day NFL updates direct to your inbox.

Signal Up

Keefer: The Chargers-Bengals sport was probably the greatest of the season — Herbert went wild within the first half, then Joe Burrow put collectively a few of the greatest soccer I’ve ever seen him play within the second. The intriguing layer of the Harbaugh matchup Monday evening is how Lamar Jackson bounces again from final week’s loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers (his -0.21 EPA per dropback and 66.1 passer score have been season lows). Jackson usually torches groups outdoors the AFC North, and a press release win Monday in opposition to an elite protection — the Chargers lead the league in scoring protection at 14.2 allowed per sport — would push him proper again in entrance of the MVP race.

It’s time for the biweekly NFC West temperature examine. The Los Angeles Rams (5-5) host a sizzling Philadelphia Eagles workforce Sunday evening. The San Francisco 49ers (5-5) are on the street in opposition to the Inexperienced Bay Packers. The Cardinals (6-4) and Seattle Seahawks (5-5) meet. Which workforce is in one of the best place to win the division?

Howe: I appreciated the Cardinals as a enjoyable shock workforce this season, however I didn’t anticipate they’d be a critical division risk, even when accidents amongst their opponents are a giant cause. I’ll follow the Cardinals as a result of they’re enjoying one of the best and proceed to get higher. I do just like the Seahawks and suppose they’re neck and neck with Arizona, so their two conferences within the subsequent three weeks might very properly inform the story on this division race. Seattle must focus extra on the run sport, although, and the O-line accidents have been problematic. The Niners nonetheless have the best ceiling within the division, however they’ve been freely giving too many video games and I’m not able to assume that sample is about to magically break. The Rams have been too inconsistent, though I can’t rule out Matthew Stafford’s flipping a change and protecting them within the combine.

Kyler Murray and the Arizona Cardinals may very well be one of many league’s shock groups at 6-4 and atop the NFC West. (Stacy Revere / Getty Pictures)

Sando: The Athletic’s mannequin offers the Cardinals a 58 p.c probability of successful the division, adopted by the Rams (23 p.c), the 49ers (12 p.c) and the Seahawks (8 p.c). Is it actually that lopsided? I see this division coming right down to the ultimate week, when San Francisco visits Arizona and the Rams go to Seattle. All 4 groups might have a shot at 9-8. Any workforce attending to 10-7 most likely will win the division. I don’t see any workforce with a giant benefit, however I query whether or not the 49ers can keep wholesome sufficient to prevail.

Keefer: The Cardinals are enjoying one of the best of any workforce within the division, and as Jeff famous, these two conferences with the Seahawks might find yourself deciding the NFC West title. (San Francisco and L.A. have been too inconsistent.) However crucial this time of 12 months are the groups which can be displaying tangible indicators of enchancment, and the Cardinals match the invoice: Arizona has received 4 straight, together with its final two by a mixed 45 factors. In three of these wins the protection allowed lower than 16 factors. On offense, Kyler Murray has been lighting it up. By mid-January, I just like the Cardinals to win their first division title since 2015.

(Prime picture of Bo Nix: Dustin Bradford / Getty Pictures)